Part 1 of 2
In today's evolving higher education landscape, strategic technology investments are more critical than ever. As institutions face increasing pressure to enhance student outcomes, improve operational efficiencies, and stay competitive, digital transformation plays an important role. Key trends such as the shift to cloud-based solutions, the need for data-driven decision-making, and the growing focus on student success and engagement are reshaping how higher education institutions operate. However, these advancements must be balanced against a complex financial environment marked by limited resources, slow enrollment growth, rising operational costs, and competing institutional priorities. Given this reality, CIOs, COOs, and other higher education leaders must demonstrate the long-term value of their technology investments to a wide range of stakeholders, potentially including university leadership, faculty, staff, students, and state legislatures.
As financial constraints push for greater accountability, the need for a clear return on investment (ROI) becomes more pressing. Institutions are re-evaluating budget allocations to ensure that spending maximizes impact while minimizing risk. This means aligning technology investments not only with strategic goals but also with efforts to optimize spending, reduce overhead, and redirect resources to mission-critical areas such as teaching, research, and student support.
Key Considerations in Building a Value Proposition
Building an effective business case for technology investments comes with its own set of challenges. Factors include:
Aligning Technology Investments with Institution Priorities
Technology investments must directly support an institution's strategic objectives. Leaders face the challenge of demonstrating how these investments contribute to long-term success and align with the institution’s mission.
Balancing Measurable Outcomes with Hard-to-Quantify Benefits
Quantifiable benefits, such as cost savings, are straightforward, but intangible benefits—like enhanced student experiences, or improved faculty productivity—are harder to estimate and convey but are critical to creating a complete and accurate ROI.
Separating Relevant Data from Irrelevant Data
The era of big data presents us with so much information — and misinformation — that CIOs, COOs, and others must figure out how to acquire data from disparate sources, discard irrelevant data, and keep valuable, pertinent information to produce an accurate ROI analysis.
Directly Addressing Stakeholder Concerns
Securing buy-in for technology investments often requires addressing stakeholder, including end user, concerns about the perceived high costs and disruptions associated with new technology investments, such as SaaS modernization. As Mike Thompson, Senior Director of Methodology and Tooling at Ellucian, notes, "There's a trust component to this as well". Buy-in hinges on addressing fears around disruption, change management, and the impact on day-to-day work, ensuring stakeholders feel confident in the investment's value.
ROI as a Strategic Imperative in Technology Modernization
A successful ROI analysis, or value proposition, for technology investments is more than a financial calculation—it's a strategic exercise that shapes priorities and drives transformative change. "An ROI goes beyond just a cost comparison; it also focuses on 'What are the total benefits that might be received at an institution?'" explains Caroline Mueller, Senior Customer Impact Manager at Ellucian.
This strategic approach ensures that investments resonate with diverse stakeholders—students, faculty, staff, administrators and Boards—by demonstrating both direct and indirect benefits. By aligning technology initiatives with institutional goals and showcasing measurable outcomes alongside qualitative impacts, higher education leaders can build a compelling case for modernization.
Ultimately, ROI serves as a decision-making framework that connects financial feasibility to an institution’s broader mission, ensuring that investments deliver sustainable and strategic value.
In Part Two of this guide, we will explore practical best practices for crafting an effective business case for major technology investments.
Join webinar and receive the Forrester TEI report for in-depth insights about Colleague SaaS and best practices to build an ROI case to support your investment in new technology.
